“Spooky Jack-o’-Lantern Stuffed Bell Peppers in 30 Minutes”

Name: "Spooky Jack-o'-Lantern Stuffed Bell Peppers in 30 Minutes"
Prep time: 20 min
Cook time: 35 min
Total time: 55 min
Cuisine: American
Ingredients: 4 large orange bell peppers; 1 lb ground beef (or turkey for a lighter option); 1 cup cooked rice; 1 small onion, diced; 2 cloves garlic, minced; 1 can (14.5 oz) diced tomatoes, drained; 1 tsp paprika; 1 tsp dried oregano; Salt and pepper to taste; 1 cup shredded cheese (cheddar or mozzarella); 2 tbsp olive oil

Author: lia

Published: August 16, 2025

Updated: August 16, 2025

Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe

You know Halloween’s coming when the grocery stores overflow with those gorgeous orange bell peppers – and I immediately start dreaming about Jack-o’-Lantern Stuffed Bell Peppers! These aren’t your average stuffed peppers, friends. I first made them years ago when my niece begged for “spooky dinner,” and now they’re our October tradition. The best part? That golden cheese melting through the carved pumpkin faces makes everyone giggle before they even take a bite. Trust me, these savory stuffed peppers taste as good as they look, with the perfect balance of hearty filling and sweet roasted pepper.

Table of Contents

Ingredients:

4 large orange bell peppers
1 lb of ground beef (or an option to follow but not necessary) 1 cup cooked rice
1 small onion, diced
2 cloves of garlic minced
1 can of tomatoes (14.5 oz) diced tomatoes
1 tsp of paprika
1 tsp of oregano
1 tsp of salt and pepper to taste
1 cup of shredded cheese (cheddar or mo)
2 tbsp of olive oil

How to Make Jack-o’-Lantern Stuffed Bell Peppers

Okay, let’s get spooky! Here’s my foolproof method for making these adorable (and delicious) Jack-o’-Lantern peppers – I’ve made this recipe so many times I could probably do it in my sleep!

Jack-o'-Lantern Stuffed Bell Peppers - detail 1

Prep those peppers: First things first – slice off the tops about 1/2 inch down (save them!) and scoop out all the seeds and white membranes. Pro tip: A grapefruit spoon works miracles for this!
Sauté the aromatics: Heat your olive oil in a large skillet over medium heat. Add the diced onion and garlic, stirring until they’re soft and fragrant – about 3 minutes. This builds the flavor base, so don’t rush it!
Brown the beef: Crumble in your ground beef, breaking it up with a wooden spoon. Cook until there’s no pink left – about 5-7 minutes. Drain off any excess fat (I just tilt the pan and use a spoon to remove it).
Bring it all together: Stir in the rice, drained tomatoes, and all your spices. Let everything get friendly for another 2 minutes. The mixture should be moist but not watery – if it looks too dry, add a splash of beef broth.
Stuff ’em up: Pack the filling tightly into your pepper shells – I like to mound it slightly over the top. Place them in a baking dish (the saved pepper tops make cute “lids” if you want!).
Bake to perfection: Pop them in a 375°F oven for 25-30 minutes. You’ll know they’re ready when the peppers start to soften and get those delicious roasted edges.
Cheese please! Sprinkle the shredded cheese on top during the last 5 minutes of baking. Watch carefully – you want it melted and bubbly, not browned.

Jack-o'-Lantern Stuffed Bell Peppers - detail 2

Carving the Jack-o’-Lantern Faces

Here’s where the magic happens! Wait until after baking to carve – raw peppers are too firm and you risk tearing them. I use a small paring knife (bonus points if it’s Halloween-themed!).

Keep it simple: two triangles for eyes, one triangle nose, and a zigzag mouth. Press gently and make small cuts – you can always widen them. The steam escaping through the face makes it look extra spooky when serving! Pro tip: Save the cut-out pieces – they make great “pumpkin seeds” to garnish the plate.

Tips for Perfect Jack-o’-Lantern Stuffed Bell Peppers

After making these Halloween cuties dozens of times, I’ve learned all the little tricks that take them from “nice try” to “wow, how’d you do that?” Here are my can’t-live-without tips:

Pick peppers with personality: Look for ones that sit flat naturally – wobbly peppers make messy carvers! Thick walls hold their shape better during baking. And don’t be shy about giving them a little squeeze – you want firm, not soft.
Drain those tomatoes like your dinner depends on it: Seriously, I press mine in a fine mesh strainer for a full minute. A soggy filling means droopy Jack-o’-Lantern faces, and nobody wants that.
Let them rest before carving: I know it’s tempting to start right away, but wait 5 minutes after baking. The peppers firm up slightly, making cleaner cuts. Trust me, your triangle eyes will thank you!
Cookie cutters are your secret weapon: For picture-perfect faces every time, I use a tiny triangle cookie cutter (the kind for fondant work). Just press gently into the warm pepper – instant professional results!
Undercook the rice slightly: That extra 5 minutes in the oven will finish cooking it. Mushy rice = sad stuffed peppers. I cook mine al dente (about 2 minutes less than package directions).

Ingredient Substitutions

Listen, I get it – sometimes you’re staring at an empty fridge thinking “How am I supposed to make Jack-o’-Lantern peppers NOW?” Don’t panic! After years of last-minute Halloween recipe rescues, I’ve got your back with these smart swaps that still deliver on flavor and fun.

Turkey or lentils instead of beef

Ground turkey (93% lean works best) makes a fantastic lighter option – just add an extra teaspoon of olive oil since it’s leaner. The texture stays beautifully tender, though you might miss that rich beefy flavor. My vegetarian friends swear by brown lentils – cook them until just tender (about 20 minutes) and mash slightly. They’ll give you that hearty bite without falling apart.

Quinoa for rice

Ran out of rice? No problem! Quinoa adds a nice nutty flavor and actually holds the filling together better than rice. Use 1 cup cooked quinoa (about 1/3 cup dry) – it’ll absorb more liquid though, so you might need an extra splash of broth. The tiny grains make the filling look more uniform too, if you’re into that.

Vegan cheese alternatives

For dairy-free Jack-o’-Lanterns, I’ve had great results with Violife or Daiya cheddar-style shreds. They melt surprisingly well, though they don’t get quite as golden. Pro tip: Sprinkle nutritional yeast in the filling too – it gives that umami boost vegan cheese sometimes lacks. The texture stays creamy rather than stretchy, but hey – the spooky faces still steal the show!

Honestly? The best part about this recipe is how forgiving it is. Whether you’re swapping ingredients by choice or necessity, those grinning pepper faces will still make everyone at the table smile.

Storing and Reheating Jack-o’-Lantern Stuffed Bell Peppers

Now, I know Halloween leftovers might not sound exciting, but trust me – these stuffed peppers taste even better the next day! The flavors have more time to mingle and get cozy together. Here’s how I store mine so they stay as fresh-looking (and tasting) as possible:

Refrigerator storage: Let the peppers cool completely first – about 30 minutes. Then pop them in an airtight container (I line mine with paper towels to absorb extra moisture). They’ll keep beautifully for up to 3 days this way. Pro tip: If you’ve already carved the faces, store them face-up to prevent squishing!

Reheating: My favorite method is in the oven at 350°F for 10-15 minutes – just until heated through. This keeps the texture perfect and prevents sogginess. If you’re in a hurry, you can microwave them (about 2 minutes per pepper), but be warned – those cute Jack-o’-Lantern faces might lose their definition when nuked. I learned this the hard way when my carefully carved smile turned into a sad, droopy frown!

Freezing: While you can freeze these (unbaked is best), I don’t recommend it if you’ve carved the faces – thawed peppers get too soft to hold the shapes. But the filling freezes great on its own for up to 2 months! Just thaw overnight in the fridge and stuff into fresh peppers when ready to bake.

Nutritional Information

Let’s be real – we’re not eating Jack-o’-Lantern Stuffed Bell Peppers because they’re a diet food (though honestly, they’re pretty balanced!). But I always like knowing what I’m putting into my body, even when it’s covered in melted cheese and carved into a silly face. Here’s the breakdown per serving:

Calories: About 320
Protein: 20g (thanks to all that beef and cheese!)
Carbohydrates: 22g
Fiber: 4g
Fat: 18g
Sodium: Around 450mg

Now, a little disclaimer from your favorite chaotic kitchen witch: These numbers are estimates only. Your actual nutrition will vary depending on the brands you use, how much cheese you “accidentally” add (we’ve all been there), and whether you go for beef or turkey. The rice vs quinoa swap changes things too – quinoa bumps up the protein a bit!

But here’s my philosophy – it’s Halloween! If you’re going to splurge, do it on something homemade and fun like these peppers rather than a bag of candy. At least you’re getting actual vegetables in between all that cheese melting through the jack-o’-lantern grin!

Frequently Asked Questions

Over the years of making these Jack-o’-Lantern Stuffed Bell Peppers, I’ve gotten the same few questions again and again. Here are the answers I always give, learned through trial and error (and the occasional kitchen disaster!).

Can I use green bell peppers instead of orange?
Absolutely! They’ll taste just as delicious, though I’ll admit – the orange ones make for much more convincing Jack-o’-Lanterns. If you do use green peppers, try adding a pinch of sugar to balance their slightly bitter flavor. Bonus: Purple peppers make wonderfully spooky Halloween creations too!

How do I prevent my stuffed peppers from getting soggy?
Oh honey, I feel this one in my soul! Two key things: First, drain those canned tomatoes like your life depends on it – I actually pat mine dry with paper towels. Second, don’t overstuff the peppers. Leave about 1/4 inch at the top so the filling has room to expand without spilling over and making the bottoms mushy. And always bake them on a rack if you can!

Can I prepare these ahead of time?
You bet! Here’s my make-ahead trick: Cook the filling completely and store it separately from the peppers. The mixture keeps beautifully in the fridge for 2 days. When you’re ready, stuff the peppers and bake as usual – they might need an extra 5 minutes since everything’s cold. Just don’t carve the faces until after baking!

Got more questions? Slide into my DMs – I could talk about these Halloween peppers all day long!

For more delicious recipes and inspiration, check out our Pinterest page!