Spooky Witches’ Brew Punch Will Haunt Your Tastebuds

Name: Spooky Witches' Brew Punch Will Haunt Your Tastebuds
Prep time: 10 min
Total time: 10 min
Cuisine: American
Ingredients: 4 cups pineapple juice; 2 cups orange juice; 1 cup lemonade; 2 liters ginger ale, chilled; 1 cup lime sherbet; Ice cubes; Gummy worms or candy eyeballs for garnish (optional)

Author: lia

Published: August 12, 2025

Updated: September 13, 2025

Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe

Oh my gosh, you HAVE to try this Witches’ Brew Punch at your next Halloween party – it’s always the star of the show! I learned this the hard way last year when I made a single batch for my annual spooky bash. Big mistake. My guests drained the bowl in 20 minutes flat and I spent the rest of the night mixing emergency refills while dressed as a very frazzled zombie.

What makes this Halloween drink so magical? That perfect balance of fruity pineapple and orange juices with a fizzy ginger ale kick – it’s like a party in your mouth. The lime sherbet melts into this eerie green potion that bubbles and swirls when you stir it. Kids go crazy for the floating gummy worms (they look like they’re swimming!), while adults love how refreshing it is after sampling all those heavy Halloween treats.

Trust me, this Witches’ Brew Punch has become my non-negotiable Halloween tradition. The best part? It comes together in about 10 minutes flat, leaving you plenty of time to perfect your witch cackle before guests arrive.

Ingredients for Witches’ Brew Punch

Here’s everything you’ll need to whip up this magical potion:

4 cups pineapple juice (measured before pouring)
2 cups orange juice
1 cup lemonade
2 liters ginger ale, chilled (trust me, cold makes all the difference)
1 cup lime sherbet (not sorbet – the creaminess matters!)
Ice cubes to keep it frosty
Gummy worms or candy eyeballs for garnish (optional but oh-so-fun)

That’s it! Just seven simple ingredients for a punch that’ll have everyone spellbound.

How to Make Witches’ Brew Punch

Okay, let’s brew some magic! This punch comes together so fast you’ll think you’ve cast a spell. Here’s exactly how I do it:

Chill your juices first – I stick mine in the fridge for at least an hour beforehand. Cold juices mean your punch stays frosty longer without getting watered down by too much ice.
Mix the base – In your biggest punch bowl (or cauldron if you’re feeling extra witchy!), combine the pineapple juice, orange juice, and lemonade. Give it a gentle stir with your wooden spoon – I pretend it’s a magic wand for fun.
Add the fizz – Here’s the secret: pour the chilled ginger ale slowly down the side of the bowl to keep those precious bubbles intact. No vigorous stirring here!
Swirl in the sherbet – Drop scoops of lime sherbet on top and give it just 2-3 light stirs – you want those gorgeous green swirls, not a melted mess.
Finish with ice – Toss in a handful of ice cubes and serve immediately while it’s at its fizziest, creepiest best!

See? Even a kitchen newbie can whip this up between carving pumpkins and untangling spiderweb decorations!

Tips for the Best Witches’ Brew Punch

After making this punch more times than I can count (seriously, I once brewed 5 batches in one weekend!), here are my hard-earned secrets:

Chill everything first – Cold juices and ginger ale mean you’ll use less ice, keeping flavors bold instead of watered down.
Sherbet is your sweetness dial – Start with 1 cup, then taste. Want it sweeter? Add another scoop! Kids love when I make it extra sherbet-y.
Dry ice = wow factor – For that smoky cauldron effect, add a small chunk (use tongs!) right before serving. Just don’t let anyone eat it!
Stir like you’re casting a gentle spell – Over-mixing murders the bubbles. Two swirls max to preserve that magical fizz!

Follow these, and your punch will be the potion everyone’s gossiping about at the graveyard smash!

Spooky Variations of Witches’ Brew Punch

Want to put your own creepy twist on this brew? Try swapping the pineapple juice for grape juice – it turns the potion a wicked purple-black! Orange sherbet gives a haunting glow, while raspberry makes it look like vampire’s delight. For extra magic, stir in edible glitter (just a pinch—you’re enchanting, not blinding!).

Serving and Garnishing Ideas

Presentation is everything with this Witches’ Brew Punch! I always serve mine in a plastic cauldron I found at the dollar store – instant witchy vibes. Black plastic cups with spiderweb designs make every sip feel spooky. Don’t forget those candy eyeballs floating on top (they “watch” you drink!) or gummy worms crawling up the sides. Pair it with “fingers” (breadstick pretzels) or “bat wings” (blue corn chips) for a full Halloween snack spread. The creepier, the better!

Storing Witches’ Brew Punch

Here’s the cauldron truth – this punch is at its bubbling best served fresh! If you must store it, skip the ice and refrigerate for up to 2 hours (the ginger ale starts losing its magical fizz after that). I always mix a fresh batch when the first one disappears – which it will!

Witches’ Brew Punch Nutritional Information

Just between us witches, this potion isn’t exactly health food – but hey, it’s Halloween! Nutritional values are estimates since sugar content changes based on juice brands and how many gummy worms escape into your cup.

Serving size: 1 cup
Calories: 120
Sugar: 25g (mostly from the natural fruit juices)
Sodium: 15mg
Fat/Carbs/Protein: 0g each

For a lighter version, use diet ginger ale and less sherbet – but where’s the fun in that?

FAQs About Witches’ Brew Punch

Got questions about this spooky Halloween party drink? I’ve brewed up some answers to the spells—I mean, questions—I get most often:

Can I make this punch boozy? Absolutely! Add a cup of vodka or spiced rum for the grown-ups’ cauldron. Just warn your guests—it makes the magic hit harder!

How long does the fizz last? About 1-2 hours before the ginger ale starts losing its bubbly charm. That’s why I always serve it fresh.

Can I prep the sherbet ahead? Yes! Freeze scoops on parchment paper, then toss them in last minute. Melted sherbet makes the punch cloudy (still tasty, just less witchy).

Remember: the best Halloween drinks disappear fast—make extra!

Share Your Creepy Creation

Did your Witches’ Brew Punch cast a spell on your guests? Snap a pic and tag #WitchesBrewPunch so I can see your magical concoctions! Rate the recipe below and tell me how your Halloween crowd loved it I live for your spooky feedback!